Codex Multi-Perspective Copy Critique for Unsupported Claims
Review text from several perspectives and identify unsupported claims, missing details and ambiguity.
中文Install in Codex
Provide the copy and available observations in Codex. The example uses fictional product text.
- Review `.agents/skills/critique-writing/SKILL.md` and its requirements at the pinned GitHub commit.
- Create `.agents/skills/critique-writing/` in your project and save the reviewed file as `.agents/skills/critique-writing/SKILL.md`.
- Start Codex from that project's root, then type `$critique-writing` and select the matching skill.
Example task
Critique this illustrative product claim and identify the missing scope.
{"claim":"Exports work for everyone","observed":"CSV export tested only on desktop","scope":"public draft"}What to check
Flag `everyone` as unsupported, propose `CSV export tested on desktop`, and ask whether other environments have evidence.
Original SKILL.md on GitHub · Updated
Frequently asked question
Should I rewrite the entire passage?
List findings and missing evidence first. Rewrite selected lines to match what the user needs.