Review consulting report arguments and evidence in Claude Code
Check a chapter's prose, evidence, reasoning, and recommendations against its outline.
中文Install in Claude Code
A Claude Code workspace with a draft chapter and its reasoning outline. The example is a fictional library printing pilot.
- Review `.claude/skills/reviewing/SKILL.md` and its requirements at the pinned GitHub commit.
- Create `.claude/skills/reviewing/` in your project and save the reviewed file as `.claude/skills/reviewing/SKILL.md`.
- Start Claude Code from that project's root, then select `/reviewing` in the slash menu.
Example task
The chapter says that the printing pilot reduced waits, but only a satisfaction survey is available. The fixture is `{claim:'wait time decreased',evidence:'satisfaction only',proposal:'expand printers'}`.What to check
Mark `{claim:'wait time decreased',status:'unsupported'}`. Request wait measurements before and after the pilot. Describe satisfaction as the current finding and ask for evidence connecting it to printer expansion.
Original SKILL.md on GitHub · Updated
Frequently asked question
What evidence should I check for an improvement claim?
Compare the conclusion with the available evidence. Check whether the recommendations address the same documented problem. Name the missing data when evidence is insufficient.